Challenging Dogma: What My PhD in Neurobiology Taught Me About Deep Tech

Published:

October 14, 2025

Author:

Justin Brodie-Kommit, PhD

The retina has been the foundational model system for developmental neurobiology for nearly three centuries. My Ph.D. research at Johns Hopkins was dedicated to shattering a 30-year-old dogma: the absolute requirement of a single transcription factor, Atoh7, for the creation of Retinal Ganglion Cells (RGCs).

For three decades, this simple model dictated that retinal stem cells followed a strict, sequential transcription factor cascade: Atoh7 was expressed in stem cells, acting as the singular switch to turn them into RGCs. The next switch was then expressed to specify cones, and so on for all seven retinal cell types. Without Atoh7, RGCs vanished, which led to a hereditary form of blindness. Published in textbooks, this model used this elegant, single-factor dependency as a broad template for all neuronal development.

My groundbreaking work, published in Science Advances, completely upended this model. We discovered that the dramatic RGC loss was a catastrophic failure of cell survival that had masked the true biology for decades. By using advanced genetic engineering to prevent cell death in the absence of Atoh7, we uncovered a stunning truth: RGC specification is not a simple cascade, but a complex, diverse population governed by a resilient regulatory network. This discovery is critical for new treatments for retinal diseases.

This scientific victory provided the two most crucial lessons I apply every day to deep tech investment:

  • Challenging Long-Held Assumptions Leads to Impact: The prevailing assumption that the system was simple and fragile led to three decades of stalled progress. By challenging that dogma, we unlocked a resilient biological truth. This framework guides our focus on Climate-Hard-Tech: we reject fragile green premiums, instead seeking solutions that deliver superior unit economics—proof that a breakthrough is truly ready to scale and is undeniably just good business.
  • The Necessity of Cross-Functional Teams: The discovery was too complex for a single lab, requiring an 18-PhD global collaboration. This collaborative approach is the foundation of Lichen Ventures’ Layered Knowledge Ecosystem—the symbiotic network powered by our Expert Network essential to properly vet and support frontier climate-hard-tech companies.

View the pdf.

Written By

Motivated by a profound concern for vulnerable populations and ecosystems, Justin is committed to making a difference in the face of our climate crisis.

Justin Brodie-Kommit, PhD

Lichen Ventures